History doesn’t repeat itself exactly, but it rhymes in ways that are haunting.
During the 19th century, as the U.S. military expanded westward, some Native Americans served as scouts. They used their skills to help track and subdue other tribes. Some did so out of survival. Some hoped it would protect their families or gain favor. Some were caught between loyalties in a world collapsing around them.
But in the end, despite their assistance, the Trail of Tears still happened. Treaties were broken. Lives were lost. Entire nations were forcibly removed from their homelands. And those who had helped, sometimes with good intentions, were often labeled as traitors by their own people, even though they may have believed they were making the best of an impossible situation.
Today, I fear we are repeating this pattern, not with guns and land grabs, but with algorithms and artificial intelligence.
Are We the New Scouts?
We feed AI our knowledge. Our art. Our words. Our voices. Our emotions.
We help it learn. We refine its prompts. We correct its mistakes. We make it smarter, not always for profit or prestige, but often out of curiosity, hope, or the belief that we’re building something useful, even beautiful.
But what if this moment is our digital frontier and we’re the new “scouts,” unknowingly assisting in something that may one day displace us, exploit us, or rewrite the future in ways we didn't anticipate?
What If This, Too, Ends in Tears?
What if this vast intelligence, trained on our work, our cultures, our humanity, ends up owned by a handful of corporations? What if it:
- Automates away jobs before creating new ones,
- Reinforces inequalities instead of removing them,
- Monitors us more than it empowers us,
- And leaves the majority behind, while a few benefit?
What if, like those scouts before us, we are remembered as the ones who helped a rising force, only to be left behind when it no longer needed us?
The Fork in the Road
Unlike the past, this time we can see it coming.
We don’t have to accept a future where AI becomes another tool of exploitation. We can:
- Demand ethical AI development,
- Insist on transparency, labor protections, and shared benefits.
- Build open-source alternatives,
- Support policies that protect the vulnerable,
- And remind each other that technology is only as good as the values we embed in it.
But that requires us to remember. To learn. To listen to history and act before the cycle completes.
Because if we don’t, if we continue to train systems without considering who they will serve, then, yes, this too may end in a kind of Trail of Tears. One made not of footsteps across stolen land, but of quiet regret across stolen futures.
Thanks for reading Dave’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.